Adityo Pratomo and Somasi 027: Legal Analysis Under Articles 433, 434 and 441 of the 2023 Criminal Code

This post sets out the legal argument in my somasi (formal legal notice) No. 027/SOMASI/RW/VIII/2026 of 29 August 2026 to Adityo Pratomo (X: @kotakmakan), a Senior Product Manager at GoPay Indonesia. I wrote the letter myself, without counsel. A somasi is a demand letter. It is not a police report, a charge or a ruling. This is my legal reading, not a finding by any officer, prosecutor or court.
Other posts in this series: the replies of 21 October 2023, how the account is linked, why GoPay Indonesia is named and right of reply.
The legal basis
My letter relies on the 2023 Criminal Code (Law No. 1 of 2023, in force since 2 January 2026), which took over the defamation offences from the ITE Law:
- Article 433(2), written defamation: attacking someone's honour or reputation by accusing them of something, so that it becomes public, in writing.
- Article 434, slander, as an alternative basis for investigation.
- Article 441, which raises the maximum penalty by a third when the act uses information technology.
- Articles 1365, 1366 and 1372 of the Civil Code for a civil claim over an unlawful act and insult.
- Article 5(1) of the ITE Law, under which electronic information, such as these screenshots, is lawful evidence.
The elements of Article 433, as I read them
| Element | The fact I rely on |
|---|---|
| Any person | Adityo Pratomo, through @kotakmakan, linked via didit.dad and LinkedIn |
| Attack on honour or reputation | Calling me "unemployable", and telling the thread to send me to a psychologist |
| Accusing of something | That I made myself unemployable, and that my former employer "did the right thing" |
| Intent that it become public | Posted in a public X thread; the first post shows 13.7K views |
| In writing, broadcast or displayed | X posts |
| Not in the public interest or self-defence | Personal remarks about a stranger, not criticism of any public matter |
Article 434
He presented "the company did the right thing" as though he knew the reasons for my dismissal. If he had no basis for that, and cannot show one, my letter argues Article 434 may apply. I put it to the police as a point for investigation.
Article 441
Every post was made on X, an information-technology medium. That raises the maximum under Article 433(2) from 1 year 6 months to 2 years, and under Article 434 from 3 years to 4 years.
Intent
- Five posts in one thread, not one remark.
- Definite language: "seriously needs help", "making himself unemployable".
- He followed the story: "it's been about a month and he's still making an issue of this".
- He knew the stakes: a senior product manager in the same industry understands what "unemployable" does to a professional's name.

What I demanded
Within three calendar days of the letter:
- Delete the posts and replies of 21 October 2023.
- Publish an apology on @kotakmakan, acknowledging that the "unemployable" statement and the remarks about my mental health were wrong.
- Stop any further statements that harm my honour and reputation.
- Pay immaterial damages of IDR 533,333,334.
The letter also offered to settle the matter amicably by email within the same period, and set out the steps I would take otherwise: criminal reports, a civil claim under the Civil Code, notification to GoPay Indonesia and the ITB alumni association, and publication of the somasi.
Right of reply and correction policy
Adityo Pratomo is invited to reply, including on any point of law. A substantive response may be published alongside this article, subject to reasonable editing for privacy, safety and relevance. If reliable evidence shows a factual statement here is wrong, I will correct it promptly and note the change.
Published by Rahmat Wibowo, InfraLoka — infraloka.co.id
#ProfessionalBlacklist #AdityoPratomo #Somasi #KUHPBaru #UUITE #GoPay #FairRecord