Infraloka Logo
Professional Blacklist: personal dispute documentation
Professional BlacklistFarah Clarashinta RachmadyPython IndonesiaRight Of Reply

Farah Clarashinta Rachmady and a "Python Indonesia" Logo on a Forum Account: Borrowed Name or Plain Opinion?

Header illustration: a community logo on an anonymous account and why it matters

A comment signed with a person's name is that person's opinion. The same comment under a community's name and logo reads like the community's view. This post is about that difference, using accounts I attribute, with caution, to Farah Clarashinta Rachmady.

This article does not say that Python Indonesia took part in anything, and it does not state as fact who controlled the accounts. The identification is weak, as I explain in a separate post.

This is my account and my opinion. It is not a finding by any court or platform.

Scope and identity note

  • Accounts: two forum accounts showing the "Python ID" name and logo, active in September to November 2023.
  • Organization: Python Indonesia, a community of Python users in Indonesia. I have no sign that it ran or approved these accounts, and my notice to it was about its name and logo, not about wrongdoing.
  • Sources: forum screenshots, not reproduced here.

Comments I quoted in the notice

In my translation:

  1. "Ignore him, Pet :)", in a thread where another account questioned me.
  2. "Have you ever been aware of what you have been doing all this time?", addressed to my account.
  3. "What clarification do you mean?" and "Apologise for what exactly?", in a thread about a separate account.
  4. A 29 September 2023 line saying that with the current case I might need to "disappear for about two years", because once credentials are involved it is a red flag.

Why the logo matters

Without the logoWith the logo
Reads as one person's viewCan read as a community's view
Reader weighs the person's credibilityReader borrows the community's credibility
Easy to dismissHarder to dismiss, and harder to answer

My notice argued that using a community's name gives an attack a weight it would not otherwise have.

What I asked for

I asked the person to stop using any organization's name or logo on accounts she controls, and asked Python Indonesia to say publicly whether the accounts were official. I did not assume that the organization had done anything wrong.

What I cannot say

  • That any quoted line is defamatory. Several are mocking rather than factual, and a court would sort them differently.
  • That the organization knew of the accounts.
  • That the logo was used with intent to deceive. It may have been a joke.

Where I am probably wrong

Lines such as "ignore him" are ordinary forum talk. Some of what I quote may be fair comment on my public conduct, and I have been blunt in public myself. The logo question stands apart, because it concerns how others read the words.

Right of reply and correction policy

Farah Clarashinta Rachmady and Python Indonesia are invited to send a response, correction or added context. A substantive response may be published alongside this article, subject to reasonable editing for privacy, safety and relevance. If reliable evidence shows that any statement here is wrong, I will correct it promptly and note the change.

Published by Rahmat Wibowo, InfraLoka — infraloka.co.id

#ProfessionalBlacklist #FarahClarashintaRachmady #PythonIndonesia #RightOfReply