Ghozy Ul Haq and Somasi 004: Legal Analysis Under Articles 433, 434 and 441 of the 2023 Criminal Code

This post sets out the legal argument in my somasi (formal legal notice) No. 004/SOMASI/RW/VIII/2026 of 28 August 2026 to Ghozy Ul Haq (X: @ghozyulhaq), whose LinkedIn profile lists him as an analyst at OJK RI. I wrote it myself, without counsel. A somasi is a demand letter, not a police report, a charge or a ruling. This is my legal reading, not a finding by any court. I identify the account as his as explained in another post.
Other posts in this series: the reply of 21 July 2026, the repost record and the @KawalRahmatwi account, how the name is linked, why OJK RI is named and right of reply. The somasi is also summarised in an earlier post.
The legal basis
The reply is dated 21 July 2026, after the 2023 Criminal Code (Law No. 1 of 2023) took effect on 2 January 2026. My letter relies on:
- Article 433(2), written defamation: attacking someone's honour or reputation by accusing them of something, in writing that is broadcast or shown, so that it becomes public.
- Article 434, slander: the same, where the person given the chance to prove the accusation cannot, and it is contrary to what he knew.
- Article 441(1), which lets the penalty be increased by a third when information technology is used.
- Civil Code Articles 1365, 1366, 1372 and 1373, for a civil claim over an unlawful act and insult.
- Article 5(1) of the ITE Law, under which electronic information is lawful evidence.
The elements of Article 433(2), as I read them
| Element | The fact my letter relies on |
|---|---|
| Any person | Ghozy Ul Haq, through @ghozyulhaq |
| Attack on honour or reputation | The reply tells readers to read @KawalRahmatwi before believing my writing |
| By accusing of something | The letter says the reply links and adopts what the @-mentioned account says about me |
| In writing, shown publicly | A public X reply with 1,748 views, plus a repost |
| Intent that it become known | The letter reads "baca2 dulu" as an instruction to the public |
| No public-interest or self-defence ground (Art. 433(3)) | The letter says he had no stake in the dispute and did not check with me |
Article 434
My letter treats Article 434 as the subsidiary charge. It asks whether he was given the chance to prove the accusations on the account he named, could not, and whether they were contrary to what he knew. The letter says this depends on proof before a court, so I frame it as an allegation to be tested.
Article 441(1)
X is information technology. On my letter's figures, a third more takes Article 433(2) from 1 year 6 months to 2 years (fine up to Rp66,666,666.67, not Rp50,000,000), and Article 434 from 3 to 4 years (fine up to Rp266,666,666.67, not Rp200,000,000).
Intent and participation
The letter reads intent as purpose: he wrote the sentence, typed the @-mention and published it. It reads the reply and the repost as taking part in, or at least aiding, content that began on another account (Articles 20 and 21). These are my readings.
The civil claim
For Article 1365 the letter lists an act, unlawfulness, fault, loss and causation. Under Article 1372 it asks for immaterial damages of at least Rp533,333,334, twice the maximum fine it computes for Article 434 with Article 441(1). It relies on seven exhibits, B-1 to B-7.

Right of reply and correction policy
Ghozy Ul Haq is invited to reply. A substantive response may be published alongside this article, subject to reasonable editing for privacy, safety and relevance. If reliable evidence shows a factual statement here is wrong, I will correct it promptly and note the change.
Published by Rahmat Wibowo, InfraLoka — infraloka.co.id
#ProfessionalBlacklist #GhozyUlHaq #OjkRi #Somasi #NewCriminalCode #KUHP #OJK #FairRecord