Hasbi A Lubis: "Nak, Sehat Kau", Concern or Insult? The Defences I Expect

Before anyone answers my letter, I want to write down the best arguments against my position. If I am going to be corrected, I would rather be corrected by my own list.
This article does not claim that Hasbi A Lubis would make any of these arguments. It is my own stress test of Somasi No. 099. The comment, the identity issue and the facts are in the main record. This is my account and my opinion, not a finding by any court.
The defences, and my honest rating of each
| # | Possible defence | My view |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | "Nak, sehat kau" shows concern, not insult. | Medium. The concern comes after "orang gila", not in place of it. A reader or judge may still give it weight. |
| 2 | My post was a challenge ("Sini boss lawan"), so the reply was a reaction. | Weak. The post named nobody and attacked nobody. A challenge about grades does not invite a comment on a mind. |
| 3 | "Orang gila" is an everyday phrase. | Weak to medium. It was aimed at one person, in a public thread. But the phrase is common and a court may see it as rough talk. |
| 4 | The account is not his. | My weakest point. The link is by name only. That is why my first demand is a yes or no on ownership. |
| 5 | It is one comment and the matter is small. | True. That is why my demands are limited to deletion, apology, stopping and a talk about compensation, with no figure fixed by me. |
What I would accept as a good answer
- "The account is not mine." I would correct the series and remove his name.
- "It is mine, I wrote it, and I should not have." I would treat the deletion and apology as done and stop there.
- "It is mine and I disagree." I would read the reasons in good faith.
What I cannot say
- That any of these defences would fail or succeed in court.
- That he has seen the letter or this post.
- That a police complaint will be accepted. A light insult is a complaint-based offence, and I have not filed one.
Where I am probably wrong
Reading a short comment this closely may look excessive. I keep the closeness because words about the mind are the part that stays with me, not because I think the comment was large.
Right of reply and correction policy
Hasbi A Lubis is invited to send a response, correction or added context. A substantive response may be published alongside this article, subject to reasonable editing for privacy, safety and relevance. If reliable evidence shows that any factual statement here is wrong, I will correct it promptly and note the change.
Published by Rahmat Wibowo, InfraLoka — infraloka.co.id
#ProfessionalBlacklist #HasbiALubis #Somasi #RightOfReply