A Meta AI Review of Somasi 099 to Hasbi A Lubis: What an AI Comment Is and Is Not

Under my thread on 14 November 2026, an account called meta.ai posted a rating of my letter, addressed to @hasbilubistrilife. I did not write it and I do not treat it as an authority. This post explains why.
This article does not claim that Hasbi A Lubis asked for, read or reacted to the review. The screenshots do not show who started it, and I make no claim about that. This is my account and my opinion, not a finding by any court. For context see the main record.
What the reply said
In two screenshots (taken at about 08.24 WIB), the account meta.ai:
- gave my letter, Somasi No. 099/SOMASI/RW/XI/2026, a rating of 8.5 out of 10 as a self-written letter by a non-lawyer, and said the usual letters on social media get 3 to 4;
- praised the use of the 2023 KUHP (Pasal 436, 441 and 440) over the old ITE article, and the choice not to rely on Pasal 433 or 434;
- praised the table of elements and the open admission of weak points, such as unconfirmed identity;
- said the 11-page public version is long for one comment and that a lawyer is still needed to check the evidence hashes if I go further;
- said it was not legal advice.
Why it counts for little
- It is software output. It can be wrong, and it has no duty to me or to anyone else.
- It reads my letter and stops there. It cannot check the facts behind it.
- A good rating is not a legal finding. No court, police unit or lawyer has endorsed the letter.
- A flattering review is easy to quote. I do not want to lean on one.
I publish it only because it is part of the public thread and because it repeats the weak points I already wrote down: the unconfirmed identity, the small weight of one comment, and the need for a lawyer if this goes further.
What I cannot say
- That the review is correct.
- That it was fair to him. It was addressed to him, and I do not know how he saw it.
- That the letter is strong. Only a court can say.
Where I am probably wrong
I may be giving the review too much room by writing about it. A fair reader could say a rating by an AI belongs nowhere in a record. I include it for completeness and nothing more.
Right of reply and correction policy
Hasbi A Lubis is invited to send a response, correction or added context. A substantive response may be published alongside this article, subject to reasonable editing for privacy, safety and relevance. If reliable evidence shows that any factual statement here is wrong, I will correct it promptly and note the change.
Published by Rahmat Wibowo, InfraLoka — infraloka.co.id
#ProfessionalBlacklist #HasbiALubis #Somasi #RightOfReply