Nathaniel Angelius Tjahyadi and Somasi 016: Legal Analysis Under Articles 433, 434 and 441 KUHP and Article 27A of the ITE Law

This post applies my somasi to one account, @Haniyadiniel. My letter of 28 August 2026 names the account @Haniyadiniel as belonging to Nathaniel Angelius Tjahyadi, and I use that name here. It is my reading of the law, not legal advice and not a finding by any court. Article text is paraphrased from the official sources my letter quotes.
Other posts in this series: the thread of 23 October 2023, the "blocked" claim, the "unemployed" and "envious" posts, right of reply and where he appears in somasi 016. The group letter is summarised in an earlier post.
What a somasi is
A somasi is a demand letter. It is not a police report and not a court filing. Mine, number 016/SOMASI/RW/VIII/2026, is dated 28 August 2026. It went jointly to the people on its list, with a deadline of Monday 31 August 2026 at 17.00 WIB. It is summarised in an earlier post.
Which post carries which provision
The second post, the "blocked" claim, is the one that imputes a specific matter. The first and third posts go to intent: together they show what the writer meant the second to do. See the "blocked" claim.
Article 433(2) KUHP: written defamation
Law No. 1 of 2023 took effect on 2 January 2026. Article 433(1) punishes anyone who attacks another person's honour or good name by imputing a matter, intending it to become publicly known. Paragraph (2) applies when this is done in writing or an image that is broadcast. The maximum is 1 year 6 months or a category III fine, IDR 50 million. Paragraph (3) says the act is not punishable if done in the public interest or in necessary self-defence.
In my reading, the second post meets each element:
- A person: the holder of the account, whom my letter names.
- Attacks honour or good name: it says I am shut out of work.
- By imputing a matter: that Indonesian companies blocked me.
- With intent to make it public: it was posted openly on X.
- In writing, broadcast: a text post on a public account.
Article 434 KUHP: slander
If the person is given the chance to prove the truth of the matter, cannot, and the imputation is contrary to what he knows, it is slander: up to 3 years or a category IV fine, IDR 200 million. My letter says no evidence of the "blocked" claim has been shown. The element that he knew it was untrue has to be shown person by person, and I do not claim to know what he knew. That is why I ask what the post was based on.
Article 441(1) KUHP: use of information technology
The penalties in Articles 433 to 439 can be increased by one third when the act is done by information technology. That makes Article 433(2) up to 2 years and a fine up to IDR 66,666,666.67, and Article 434 up to 4 years and a fine up to IDR 266,666,666.67.
When the posts were written
The posts date from 23 October 2023, before the new code took effect. My letter's position is that acts from late 2023 fall under the former Criminal Code, and that content still online and still being broadcast after 2 January 2026 falls under the new one. Which applies is for a court.
ITE Law, Article 27A
Law No. 1 of 2024 makes it an offence to attack another person's honour or good name by imputing a matter, in electronic information made public through an electronic system. Article 45(4) sets up to 2 years and/or IDR 400 million. Article 45(6) sets slander at up to 4 years and/or IDR 750 million. It is a complaint offence under Article 45(5), so it needs a complaint from the person affected. Article 45(7) says it is not punishable if done in the public interest or in defence of oneself.
Participation, Articles 20 and 21 KUHP
These articles make a person liable for taking part in another person's offence. They matter only if participation is shown. For him, my file shows his own three posts and nothing else, and I make no claim here about anyone he may have been in contact with.
Civil Code
Articles 1365 and 1366 oblige a person to compensate loss caused by an unlawful act. Article 1372 allows a civil claim over an insult, to recover loss and restore honour and good name. Article 1373 allows a judgment to declare an act slanderous and to be posted publicly. Joint and several liability applies only to people who acted jointly.
What my letter demanded
- Remove the posts and give proof of removal.
- Stop, with a written commitment not to repeat.
- Publish an open apology on a public account for at least 30 days.
- Pay immaterial compensation of IDR 1.5 billion per reported person, set at twice the maximum fine in Article 45(6).
The letter also says I am open to a settlement with each person. Electronic posts count as evidence under Article 5(1) of the ITE Law; the capture of this thread shows the username, the text, the date and the counts of each post.

Right of reply and correction policy
Nathaniel Angelius Tjahyadi is invited to confirm or deny that @Haniyadiniel is his account, and to say what he meant by these posts. A substantive response may be published alongside this article, subject to reasonable editing for privacy, safety and relevance. If reliable evidence shows a factual statement here is wrong, I will correct it promptly and note the change.
Published by Rahmat Wibowo, InfraLoka — infraloka.co.id
#ProfessionalBlacklist #NathanielAngeliusTjahyadi #Haniyadiniel #FairRecord #KUHP #ITELaw