Insult, Opinion or Accusation? Reading Sekar Soca Sharfina's Short X Quote-Post

This post looks at one short line, "jobless, disgusting, creep behavior", written by the account @reinkarnyasi on 10 May 2026. I say that account is held by Sekar Soca Sharfina, a student at the Faculty of Art and Design (FSRD), Institut Teknologi Bandung, and I set out the link in the first post of this series. This post sets out how I read the line and how she may read it. It is my account and opinion, not a finding by any court. The legal points are my own reading, not advice and not a ruling.
Other posts in this series: what the record shows and right of reply and what I left out.
The question
When a short reply to someone else's thread says three harsh things about me, is it a statement of fact, an opinion, or an insult? The answer matters, because Indonesian law treats them differently, and because a reader should not be told that a sharp opinion is a crime.
How I read it
- A statement of fact. "Jobless" describes a personal circumstance. If that is said as fact, it can be checked and it can be wrong.
- An insult. "Disgusting" carries no information and I read it as an insult aimed at me.
- An endorsement. "Creep behavior" sits directly above a thread accusing me of conduct toward women. I read it as taking that accusation on, in her name. I deny the accusation.
My reading of the 2023 Criminal Code is that attacking a person's honour in public can fall under its provisions on defamation and insult, and that electronic posts can fall under the ITE Law. No police officer, prosecutor or court has adopted that reading here.
How she may read it
- An opinion. People are allowed to hold and voice a harsh view of a person's conduct, especially when they believe a thread they have just read.
- A reaction, not a campaign. One line on one day is not a pattern, and I have no other posts to offer on that point.
- Informal speech. On this platform, "disgusting" and "creep" are often used loosely, and a reader may not take them as factual claims.
- Criticism that may have to be borne. If I am treated as a public figure on the subject, the room for criticism is wider.
- The view of someone who has been through a public case herself. She was detained in 2025 over a meme posted on the older account. The report I hold says the detention was suspended, and shows no finding against her. That does not make this line fair to me, but it is context, and I do not rely on it either way.
I think each of these is a fair point. The difficulty for me is that the line endorses a specific accusation, and an endorsement lends weight to it.
What would change how I read it
- A clarification or deletion of the line would settle most of my concern, and I would note it here.
- Evidence that she believed the thread for a stated reason would not make the thread true, but it would change how I describe the intent.
- Evidence that the account is not hers, for example a hijack, would change what I say about everything on this page.
A written notice
I sent a written notice to her on 31 August 2026. It asks for the line to be removed or clarified, and it is copied to ITB and FSRD ITB because she is an active student there. The copy asks the campus to note the notice, and to issue its own statement and apply its student code if it sees fit. It does not ask for expulsion and says nothing about her grades.
The notice is my position. It is not a court order, and nothing follows from it unless she answers it, I take it further, or a court decides.
Where I may be wrong
- The link between the handle and her name rests on public items, not on her confirmation, and I may have joined them too readily.
- The line itself. I may be taking a fast reply too seriously.
- The law. The exact legal classification of three words is for the authorities and the courts, not for me, and I may be reading the law more broadly than they would.
Right of reply and correction policy
Sekar Soca Sharfina is invited to respond, correct or add context, and ITB and FSRD ITB may do the same. A substantive response may be published alongside this article, subject to reasonable editing for privacy, safety and relevance. If reliable evidence shows a factual statement here is wrong — including the link between the handle and her name — I will correct it promptly and note the change.
Published by Rahmat Wibowo, InfraLoka — infraloka.co.id
#ProfessionalBlacklist #SekarSocaSharfina #Reinkarnyasi #ITB #FreedomOfExpression #Defamation #FairRecord