Hafid Abi Daniswara: Why a Repost Is Thin Evidence, and Where My Complaint Is Weak

I have complained about Hafid Abi Daniswara to OJK on the strength of one repost. Here I argue against myself. This is my opinion, not a finding by any court.
Other posts in this series: the repost, the complaint to OJK, why a repost is thin evidence and right of reply.
The defences I expect, and how I rate them
| Defence | My assessment |
|---|---|
| "A repost is not an endorsement." | Real. A repost can mean many things. The complaint itself says the final judgment belongs to the examiner. |
| "The reposted post is not an insult." | True. It announces a planned police report. The complaint says reporting to the police is anyone's right. |
| "The account is not mine." | The username is not visible in my capture, only the label "Hafid". Ownership has to be confirmed. This is my weakest point. |
| "I only shared or liked someone else's post." | The level of involvement decides whether there was joint action. The complaint says it has not claimed that. |
| "It was before the new criminal code, or too long ago." | Possibly true for the criminal route. I chose an ethics route because it has no such time limit. |
| "It was off duty, on a personal account." | I agree it was a personal account. I asked only for an ethics review, not a link to his job. |
How the complaint scored the elements
For the offence of written defamation by electronic means, with joint action, the complaint rates three elements as conditional: whether the content attacks honour, whether it makes a specific accusation, and whether he took an active part. It does not rate the repost as meeting the first two. It does not rely on the article on slander at all, because that needs an accusation he had a chance to prove and failed to. In short, I did not say the repost proves the offence.
What would strengthen or end it
- Strengthen: posts of his own that make a specific accusation, with a date.
- End it: his statement that the account is not his, or a record that shows the repost was not his.
I will publish either.
Right of reply and correction policy
Hafid Abi Daniswara and Otoritas Jasa Keuangan (OJK) are invited to send a response, correction or added context. If the account I connect to him is not his, I will say so and remove his name. A substantive response may be published alongside this article, subject to reasonable editing for privacy, safety and relevance. If reliable evidence shows that a factual statement here is wrong, I will correct it promptly and note the change.
Published by Rahmat Wibowo, InfraLoka — infraloka.co.id
#ProfessionalBlacklist #HafidAbiDaniswara #OJK #OtoritasJasaKeuangan #RightOfReply