Infraloka Logo
Professional Blacklist: personal dispute documentation
Professional BlacklistHasbi A LubisStigmaMental Health

Hasbi A Lubis: "Orang Gila" and "Terganggu Jiwa", Why I Call It Stigma and Not Criticism

Header illustration: orang gila and terganggu jiwa, stigma and not criticism, Hasbi A Lubis

A Threads reply of 14 November 2026 called me "orang gila" and said I looked "terganggu jiwa". I have a mental disability. This post explains why I treat those words as stigma, and where my argument is weak.

This article does not claim that the author knew about my condition, or that the account belongs to Hasbi A Lubis of PT Jakarta Tank Terminal. That link is unconfirmed, see the profile post. This is my account and my opinion, not a finding by any court.

Criticism and stigma are different things

My post was a boastful challenge about grades. A fair reply could say it is arrogant, pointless or in poor taste. That is criticism of what I posted.

"Orang gila" and "terganggu jiwa" are not about the post. They say something about my mind, and they would read the same under any post. If you can delete the person and keep the sentence, it is criticism. Here the sentence only works with me in it.

The law I rely on

  • Pasal 7, UU No. 8 Tahun 2016 lists a right to be free from harassment, insult and negative labelling about a disability. I use it as a statement of the value the law protects. It has no criminal penalty of its own, and I say so in my letter.
  • Pasal 436 jo. Pasal 441 ayat (1) KUHP (light insult, with an added third for use of information technology) is my main basis. It is a complaint-based offence under Pasal 440, and I have not filed a complaint.
  • I do not rely on Pasal 433 or 434, because they need a specific accusation. A label is not one.
  • I do not rely on Pasal 145 of the disability law, because the comment did not block any right.

What I cannot say

  • That he knew my diagnosis. My letter says plainly that I do not claim that.
  • That "orang gila" was meant medically. It is a common insult and many people use it with no thought of illness.
  • That a court has applied any of these articles to a comment like this.
  • That I speak for everyone with a mental disability.

Where I am probably wrong

A judge may treat "orang gila" as everyday rudeness and give it little weight. The softer follow-up, "Nak, sehat kau", could be read as concern. I address that in the defences post.

Right of reply and correction policy

Hasbi A Lubis is invited to send a response, correction or added context, including a statement that the account is not his. A substantive response may be published alongside this article, subject to reasonable editing for privacy, safety and relevance. If reliable evidence shows that any factual statement here is wrong, I will correct it promptly and note the change.

Published by Rahmat Wibowo, InfraLoka — infraloka.co.id

#ProfessionalBlacklist #HasbiALubis #Stigma #MentalHealth #RightOfReply