Infraloka Logo
Professional Blacklist: personal dispute documentation
Professional BlacklistMakarim TairaA W S IndonesiaP E R A D I

Makarim & Taira S.: The PERADI Ethics Complaint, the Bareskrim Report and Article 16, Where Things Stand

Header illustration: the PERADI ethics complaint and the Bareskrim report about Makarim & Taira S., and where they stand

This post lists what I have filed that concerns the advocates of Makarim & Taira S., what each document alleges, and where my own position has moved. Everything filed is an allegation, not a finding. I am not a lawyer and I wrote all of it myself.

Other posts in this series: why the firm is named, the letter, point by point, the demand to withdraw all complaints, the legal analysis of the criminal warning, the "Amazon" accounts and the "lawyer Makarim" comment and right of reply.

Who is named

The Surat Tanggapan of 14 July 2026 was sent for AWS Indonesia by the advocates of Makarim & Taira S. In my filings I name: Rudy Andreas Sitorus, S.H., Reagan Roy Teguh, B.Com., S.H. and Made Susanti, S.H. as the signatories of the letter; Hendrik Alfian Pasaribu, S.H., Mutiara Handaniah, S.H., Tania Rahel Lumongga Hutapea, S.H., Charissa Naomi Witantra, S.H. and Angel Risha, S.H. as further recipients of the power of attorney of 6 May 2026; and Donald Tirtaatmadja, who signed that power of attorney for AWS Indonesia as "Director". Two other people appear in my filings on the same documents: Anthony Amni, whom my Bareskrim report, from my own search of public directory data, gives as AWS Indonesia's Country Manager and President Director, the comparison I use when I question the "Director" title on the power of attorney; and Dian Hamama, the AWS Indonesia human-resources officer who ended my employment in September 2023 and who, my Polda Metro Jaya complaint says, helped coordinate and instruct the facts behind the power of attorney and the mediation statements. I hold no registry finding on Mr Amni's role, and what I say about Ms Hamama is an allegation in a complaint. I name them because my complaints do. A name here is not a finding or an accusation of guilt: what I allege is in the filings, and it is for PERADI, the police and the courts to decide.

Who is named in my filings on Makarim & Taira S. and AWS Indonesia

1. The ethics complaint to PERADI, 16 July 2026

Two days after the letter of 14 July 2026 I made an ethics complaint to the national board of the advocates' association, PERADI (its honorary council), against the advocates who received the power of attorney of 6 May 2026: Rudy Andreas Sitorus, Reagan Roy Teguh and Made Susanti as signatories of the letter, and Hendrik Alfian Pasaribu, Mutiara Handaniah, Tania Rahel Lumongga Hutapea, Charissa Naomi Witantra and Angel Risha as the other recipients. It relies on the Indonesian Advocates Code of Ethics and on Article 6(b), (d) and (f) in conjunction with Article 7 of the Advocates Law (Law 18 of 2003).

It raises three things about the letter:

  1. Allegations of breach of conduct and disclosure of confidential material, made without a URL, a date or any evidence.
  2. A warning of criminal sanctions under the Criminal Code and the electronic-transactions law, without mapping them to any element of an offence.
  3. Point 12, which asks me to withdraw all claims to any institution or authority, which the complaint says tries to block access to the official forums.

I told AWS Indonesia and the firm about the complaint by email on 7 August 2026. I know of no decision, hearing date or reply from PERADI. An ethics process runs on its own track and does not depend on the industrial-relations case or the police matters.

2. The report to Bareskrim, 13 August 2026

My public-complaint report No. 006/ADUAN/RW/08/2026, filed with the cyber-crime directorate at Bareskrim Polri, names several parties, among them Donald Tirtaatmadja (as signatory of the power of attorney) and the advocates named above at Makarim & Taira S., for the alleged use of a power of attorney and for what it calls coercion by criminal warning. The same report questions whether Donald Tirtaatmadja, who signed the power of attorney as "Director", was registered as a director on that date. I hold no company-registry finding on that point.

This report is a complaint to the police. Whether any element is met is for the investigators, and I know of no result.

3. Letter 078, 1 November 2026: a narrower view

Letter 078 says, in terms, that it contains no criminal accusation against the advocates who signed the letter, and that I direct responsibility for its contents to the principal, with Article 16 of the Advocates Law in mind. That article says an advocate cannot be prosecuted, civilly or criminally, for carrying out professional duties in good faith in defence of a client in a court hearing. Its elucidation says "good faith" means doing the work for justice under the law in defence of the client's interests, and that "court hearing" means a hearing at any level of any court.

I do not decide whether Article 16 reaches a demand letter sent outside a court hearing. Letter 078 also says that, after re-reading the official text, I do not say Article 448 is met.

The two documents differ

The Bareskrim report of 13 August 2026 names the advocates. Letter 078 of 1 November 2026 says it makes no criminal accusation against them. I say so openly instead of leaving a reader to find it. The report is a filed complaint, and I have not withdrawn it. Letter 078 is my later and narrower view. If I amend or withdraw any filing, I will say so here.

Record card: the PERADI complaint, the Bareskrim report and Article 16

Right of reply and correction policy

Makarim & Taira S. and PT Amazon Web Services Indonesia are invited to reply. If a reply to any of my letters was sent and did not reach me, please send a copy and I will correct this post. A substantive response may be published alongside this article, subject to reasonable editing for privacy, safety and relevance. If reliable evidence shows a factual statement here is wrong, I will correct it promptly and note the change.

Published by Rahmat Wibowo, InfraLoka — infraloka.co.id

#ProfessionalBlacklist #MakarimTaira #AWSIndonesia #PERADI #Bareskrim #Article16AdvocatesLaw #RightOfReply #RudyAndreasSitorus #ReaganRoyTeguh #MadeSusanti #DonaldTirtaatmadja #AnthonyAmni #DianHamama #KuasaHukum