Infraloka Logo
Professional Blacklist: personal dispute documentation
Professional BlacklistMakarim TairaA W S IndonesiaSurat Tanggapan

Makarim & Taira S.: The Demand to Withdraw All Complaints in 14 Days

Header illustration: point 12 of the Makarim & Taira S. letter, the demand to withdraw all complaints

This post is about point 12 of the Surat Tanggapan that Makarim & Taira S. sent me on 14 July 2026 for AWS Indonesia, and what Indonesian criminal procedure says about withdrawing a complaint. I am not a lawyer. This is my reading of the law and my answer, not a court finding.

Other posts in this series: why the firm is named, the letter, point by point, the legal analysis of the criminal warning, the "Amazon" accounts and the "lawyer Makarim" comment, the PERADI complaint and the Bareskrim report and right of reply.

Who is named

The Surat Tanggapan of 14 July 2026 was sent for AWS Indonesia by the advocates of Makarim & Taira S. In my filings I name: Rudy Andreas Sitorus, S.H., Reagan Roy Teguh, B.Com., S.H. and Made Susanti, S.H. as the signatories of the letter; Hendrik Alfian Pasaribu, S.H., Mutiara Handaniah, S.H., Tania Rahel Lumongga Hutapea, S.H., Charissa Naomi Witantra, S.H. and Angel Risha, S.H. as further recipients of the power of attorney of 6 May 2026; and Donald Tirtaatmadja, who signed that power of attorney for AWS Indonesia as "Director". Two other people appear in my filings on the same documents: Anthony Amni, whom my Bareskrim report, from my own search of public directory data, gives as AWS Indonesia's Country Manager and President Director, the comparison I use when I question the "Director" title on the power of attorney; and Dian Hamama, the AWS Indonesia human-resources officer who ended my employment in September 2023 and who, my Polda Metro Jaya complaint says, helped coordinate and instruct the facts behind the power of attorney and the mediation statements. I hold no registry finding on Mr Amni's role, and what I say about Ms Hamama is an allegation in a complaint. I name them because my complaints do. A name here is not a finding or an accusation of guilt: what I allege is in the filings, and it is for PERADI, the police and the courts to decide.

Who is named in my filings on Makarim & Taira S. and AWS Indonesia

What point 12 demands

Within 14 calendar days of the date of the letter, that is by 28 July 2026, the letter demands that I:

  • (a) remove and stop publishing "any and all statements, materials, or content concerning our Client"; and
  • (b) withdraw "all claims, allegations, and demands made against our Client to any institutions or authorities".

Surat Tanggapan page 7: points 12 and 13, the demands and the reservation of rights

Point 13 then reserves the client's civil and criminal rights.

Why I refused 12(b)

The Criminal Code of 2023 (Law 1 of 2023) deals with complaints in Articles 28 to 30:

  • Article 28: a complaint is a notice together with a request that the matter be prosecuted, made orally or in writing to the competent official.
  • Article 29: a complaint must be made within six months of the person entitled to complain learning of the offence (nine months if they live abroad).
  • Article 30: the complainant may withdraw a complaint within three months of filing it, and a withdrawn complaint cannot be filed again.

Three things follow, as I read them.

  1. Only the complainant can withdraw, and only within three months. My police report of 23 July 2026 passed that window on 23 October 2026. My Bareskrim receipt of 4 May 2026 passed it on 4 August 2026. My report of 13 August 2026 had until 13 November 2026, and I did not withdraw it.
  2. For an offence that is not a complaint offence, a complainant's withdrawal does not stop an investigation.
  3. I cannot "withdraw" the industrial-relations process either. That ran at the manpower office and ended with a recommendation I accepted on its own terms.

So part of the demand could not be carried out in law even if I wanted to.

Why I refused 12(a) as drafted

Point 12(a) reaches every statement "concerning our Client". That covers statements that are true and documents that are official, such as the mediator's letters. I did not agree to remove those.

What I did offer, in letter 078, is this: if AWS Indonesia names a specific statement it says is untrue, with the quote, date, platform and reason, I will assess it and correct or remove it within seven days of receiving the details if it proves wrong. I also said I do not claim every statement I have made is free of error.

The other reading

A reader could say that a client asking a person to stop publishing and to settle all disputes is ordinary, and that point 13 only reserves rights. I accept that reserving rights is ordinary, and my letter says so. My objection is narrower: the request to withdraw complaints to "any institutions or authorities" asks me to give up access to the police, the mediator and other bodies, not to correct a mistake. Whether it goes further than that is for others to judge, and I discuss the one criminal provision I looked at in the legal analysis.

Record card: the demand to withdraw all complaints

Right of reply and correction policy

Makarim & Taira S. and PT Amazon Web Services Indonesia are invited to reply. If a reply to any of my letters was sent and did not reach me, please send a copy and I will correct this post. A substantive response may be published alongside this article, subject to reasonable editing for privacy, safety and relevance. If reliable evidence shows a factual statement here is wrong, I will correct it promptly and note the change.

Published by Rahmat Wibowo, InfraLoka — infraloka.co.id

#ProfessionalBlacklist #MakarimTaira #AWSIndonesia #SuratTanggapan #Point12 #RightOfReply #RudyAndreasSitorus #ReaganRoyTeguh #MadeSusanti #DonaldTirtaatmadja #AnthonyAmni #DianHamama #KuasaHukum