Infraloka Logo
Professional Blacklist: personal dispute documentation
Professional BlacklistMakarim TairaA W S IndonesiaSurat Tanggapan

Makarim & Taira S.: The Criminal Warning at Point 11, Articles 433, 441 and 448 KUHP

Header illustration: legal analysis of point 11 of the Makarim & Taira S. letter under the 2023 Criminal Code

This post sets out, as I read them, the elements of the criminal provisions that point 11 of the Makarim & Taira S. letter of 14 July 2026 points toward, and where my own analysis stops. I am not a lawyer and I wrote this without counsel. It is analysis, not a court finding, and it does not say anyone committed an offence.

Other posts in this series: why the firm is named, the letter, point by point, the demand to withdraw all complaints, the "Amazon" accounts and the "lawyer Makarim" comment, the PERADI complaint and the Bareskrim report and right of reply.

Who is named

The Surat Tanggapan of 14 July 2026 was sent for AWS Indonesia by the advocates of Makarim & Taira S. In my filings I name: Rudy Andreas Sitorus, S.H., Reagan Roy Teguh, B.Com., S.H. and Made Susanti, S.H. as the signatories of the letter; Hendrik Alfian Pasaribu, S.H., Mutiara Handaniah, S.H., Tania Rahel Lumongga Hutapea, S.H., Charissa Naomi Witantra, S.H. and Angel Risha, S.H. as further recipients of the power of attorney of 6 May 2026; and Donald Tirtaatmadja, who signed that power of attorney for AWS Indonesia as "Director". Two other people appear in my filings on the same documents: Anthony Amni, whom my Bareskrim report, from my own search of public directory data, gives as AWS Indonesia's Country Manager and President Director, the comparison I use when I question the "Director" title on the power of attorney; and Dian Hamama, the AWS Indonesia human-resources officer who ended my employment in September 2023 and who, my Polda Metro Jaya complaint says, helped coordinate and instruct the facts behind the power of attorney and the mediation statements. I hold no registry finding on Mr Amni's role, and what I say about Ms Hamama is an allegation in a complaint. I name them because my complaints do. A name here is not a finding or an accusation of guilt: what I allege is in the filings, and it is for PERADI, the police and the courts to decide.

Who is named in my filings on Makarim & Taira S. and AWS Indonesia

What point 11 says

The letter says the client is aware that I "uploaded and/or published incorrect statements which disparage or at least cause negative perceptions towards our Client and various other third parties", and reminds me that my actions "can be considered violations subject to criminal sanctions under the provisions of the penal code and/or laws on electronic information and transactions".

Surat Tanggapan page 7: point 11, the warning of criminal sanctions

No statement, date, platform or address is named.

Article 433, and why I say it does not fit as written

Article 433 of Law 1 of 2023 punishes a person who attacks another's honour or good name by alleging something, intending it to become public. Paragraph (2) covers written or pictured material displayed or broadcast in public. Paragraph (3) says it is not punishable if done in the public interest or in necessary self-defence. Article 441(1) adds one third to the penalty if an information-technology means is used.

The official elucidation of Article 433(1), as I read it, says the object of the offence is an individual, and that insulting a government body or a group is not covered. Article 440 makes it a complaint offence, which means it is prosecuted only if the victim complains.

Applied to point 11, my letter makes three points:

  1. The letter speaks of harm to "our Client", a company. If the provision protects individuals, that is a gap.
  2. It is a complaint offence, so the person said to be defamed must complain. The letter does not say who.
  3. With no statement named, no element can be tested: not the allegation, not the intent, not the public interest or self-defence in paragraph (3).

Article 448, the one I looked at and did not claim

Article 448(1)(b) punishes forcing someone to do, not do or tolerate something by threatening defamation or written defamation. I looked at it because point 12(b) asks me to withdraw complaints and point 11 sits right before it.

My conclusion in letter 078 is that the elements are not met. A warning that conduct may be reported is not a threat to defame me. The reservation of rights in point 13 is ordinary. I wrote that I do not declare Article 448 fulfilled, and that I cited it to show its limits.

What I did say is that the weak link in point 12 is its purpose and reach, not its form, and that the points that cut the other way are the substantive answers the letter does give to some of my claims (points 1 to 10) and the 14-day deadline being a common feature of demand letters.

What I do not say

  • That the firm or its advocates committed an offence in this letter. Letter 078 says it contains no criminal accusation against them, and cites Article 16 of the Advocates Law, which I discuss in another post.
  • That any statement of mine is beyond challenge. I have asked for the statements to be named.
  • That prosecutors or courts would agree with my reading. They decide.

Record card: legal analysis of the criminal warning at point 11

Right of reply and correction policy

Makarim & Taira S. and PT Amazon Web Services Indonesia are invited to reply. If a reply to any of my letters was sent and did not reach me, please send a copy and I will correct this post. A substantive response may be published alongside this article, subject to reasonable editing for privacy, safety and relevance. If reliable evidence shows a factual statement here is wrong, I will correct it promptly and note the change.

Published by Rahmat Wibowo, InfraLoka — infraloka.co.id

#ProfessionalBlacklist #MakarimTaira #AWSIndonesia #SuratTanggapan #KUHP2023 #Pasal433 #RightOfReply #RudyAndreasSitorus #ReaganRoyTeguh #MadeSusanti #DonaldTirtaatmadja #AnthonyAmni #DianHamama #KuasaHukum