Makarim & Taira S. Letter of 14 July 2026, Point by Point

This post summarises the thirteen points of the Surat Tanggapan sent to me on behalf of AWS Indonesia by Makarim & Taira S. on 14 July 2026, and my answer of 1 November 2026. It is my reading of a letter I hold, not a finding. I wrote my answer without counsel.
Other posts in this series: why the firm is named, the demand to withdraw all complaints, the legal analysis of the criminal warning, the "Amazon" accounts and the "lawyer Makarim" comment, the PERADI complaint and the Bareskrim report and right of reply.
Who is named
The Surat Tanggapan of 14 July 2026 was sent for AWS Indonesia by the advocates of Makarim & Taira S. In my filings I name: Rudy Andreas Sitorus, S.H., Reagan Roy Teguh, B.Com., S.H. and Made Susanti, S.H. as the signatories of the letter; Hendrik Alfian Pasaribu, S.H., Mutiara Handaniah, S.H., Tania Rahel Lumongga Hutapea, S.H., Charissa Naomi Witantra, S.H. and Angel Risha, S.H. as further recipients of the power of attorney of 6 May 2026; and Donald Tirtaatmadja, who signed that power of attorney for AWS Indonesia as "Director". Two other people appear in my filings on the same documents: Anthony Amni, whom my Bareskrim report, from my own search of public directory data, gives as AWS Indonesia's Country Manager and President Director, the comparison I use when I question the "Director" title on the power of attorney; and Dian Hamama, the AWS Indonesia human-resources officer who ended my employment in September 2023 and who, my Polda Metro Jaya complaint says, helped coordinate and instruct the facts behind the power of attorney and the mediation statements. I hold no registry finding on Mr Amni's role, and what I say about Ms Hamama is an allegation in a complaint. I name them because my complaints do. A name here is not a finding or an accusation of guilt: what I allege is in the filings, and it is for PERADI, the police and the courts to decide.

The letter
Surat Tanggapan No. 00237/3513.120/VII/2026/RRT-RAS-MSS-FMR is a bilingual letter on the firm's letterhead. It answers my first somasi. It sets out the employment, the end of it on 22 September 2023, the refusal of entry to AWS Cloud Day on 26 September 2023, a reply to my email of 27 September 2023, a statement about accounts on a forum, a warning, a demand and a reservation of rights.
What the letter itself confirms
My answer begins with what the letter confirms, because I do not need to prove what the other side has written:
- I worked at AWS Indonesia from 7 August 2023, on a three-month probation (point 2).
- Notice was given on 14 September 2023, effective 22 September 2023, eight calendar days (point 4(a)).
- I was in Singapore that day, which the letter says I went to voluntarily and without asking permission (point 4(d)).
- Before the dismissal there were only "verbal warnings and coaching" (point 4(c)).
- On 26 September 2023 I tried to enter AWS Cloud Day, the team was asked not to let me in, my badge was taken and I was escorted out, which drew the attention of other attendees (points 5 to 8).
- The reason for that request was my earlier posts, not my behaviour at the event (points 5 and 6).
- AWS says it will keep monitoring my post-employment obligations (point 4(a) and Annex 2), while also saying it has no further legal relationship with me (point 9).
Where I disagree
| Point | The letter | My answer in letter 078 |
|---|---|---|
| 4(b) | Reason: "not qualified for the role" | The termination letter gives a different reason: performance "has not improved to a satisfactory standard" |
| 4(c)(i) to (iii) | Breaches: a paid CV-review website, posting internal material, internal feedback on attitude | None is in the termination letter, none is documented in the letter, and the letter says no written warning came first |
| 10 | Two "Amazon" forum accounts are not AWS accounts | I never said they were. I ask whether AWS checked who holds them. See that post |
| 11 | A warning of criminal sanctions | No statement, date or platform is named. See the legal analysis |
| 12 | Delete everything; withdraw every complaint in 14 days | Refused as drafted. See the demand post |
| 13 | Rights reserved | I reserve mine too |
One page worth reading
Page 4 of the letter carries the allegations in point 4(c). The letter attaches nothing to support them.


What I accepted and what I did not
I accepted the mediator's recommendation on the industrial-relations dispute. That acceptance covers that dispute only. It does not cover the police matters, and it does not mean I accept every statement in the letter.
Right of reply and correction policy
Makarim & Taira S. and PT Amazon Web Services Indonesia are invited to reply. If a reply to any of my letters was sent and did not reach me, please send a copy and I will correct this post. A substantive response may be published alongside this article, subject to reasonable editing for privacy, safety and relevance. If reliable evidence shows a factual statement here is wrong, I will correct it promptly and note the change.
Published by Rahmat Wibowo, InfraLoka — infraloka.co.id
#ProfessionalBlacklist #MakarimTaira #AWSIndonesia #SuratTanggapan #Letter078 #RightOfReply #RudyAndreasSitorus #ReaganRoyTeguh #MadeSusanti #DonaldTirtaatmadja #AnthonyAmni #DianHamama #KuasaHukum